Check out our Conch Republic Favorites!  

This list of personal favorite Key West restaurants comes straight from our Owner to you! Whether you’re looking for an upscale night out or the best local seafood, our staff of locals can help you find the perfect Key West dining for your needs. 

Check out the list below or talk to the friendly Concierge at The Inn at Key West for more information.

A&B Lobster House
305.294.5880
700 Front Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.7 miles

This is a great place for an exceptional seafood meal. Located in the historic seaport, guests can choose between indoor and outdoor dining both with beautiful views of the marina. With their sophisticated menu and a great wine selection you are sure to be impressed with this Key West restaurant.

Abbondonza
305.292.1199
1208 Simonton Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.6 miles 

Abbondonza in Italian means “abundance,” and that's just what you'll get! If you're craving excellent Italian food with great portions then Abbondonza will not disappoint. With its quaint setting and a wonderful selection of wine to compliment your meal, it's a great choice for a romantic night out or a large group dinner.

Blue Heaven
305.296.8666
729 Thomas Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.9 miles

Whether you eat here for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, you will come out raving about how incredible the food is. This Key West restaurant is a unique experience with great island flare located in "Bahama Village". You can dine inside, enjoy the full bar, or join the famous Key West chickens for outdoor dining.

B.O.'s Fish Wagon
(305) 294-9272
801 Caroline Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.6 miles

For the perfect fish sandwich, head to B.O.'s Fish Wagon, a hopping little open-air shack that turns out fresh food with zero fuss, as well as great live music on Friday nights.

The Commodore
305.294.9191
700 Front Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.7 miles 

Fine dining at it's BEST - this restaurant features fantastic food, great presentation, impeccable service, and a classic Key West dining atmosphere. Located in the historic seaport, with great views and wonderful menu selection, this restaurant is sure to make your evening extra special.

The Conch Republic
305.294.4403
631 Green Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.7 miles

Enjoy fresh local seafood as you watch the boats come and go at this open-air restaurant located in the historic seaport. The menu is thoughtful, each dish containing flavors that compliment each other and please your palate. Come listen to the live music and enjoy the festive atmosphere!

Duffy's Steak & Lobster
305.296.4900
1007 Simonton Street 
Distance From Hotel: 2.6 miles

Of all the seafood available at Key West restaurants, Duffy's is one of the few whose menu features dolphin—but don't worry, we aren't talking about actual dolphins, rather the breed of delicious fish! Duffy's has wonderful selections of steak and seafood, and a little something for everyone.

El Siboney
305.296.4184
900 Catherine Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.3 miles 

Local's love the great Cuban food at El Siboney! This is the place to go for classic Cuban dishes and sandwiches. Savor the unique flavors and wash down your delicious meal with a glass of homemade sangria.

Half Shell Raw Bar
305.294.7496
231 Margaret Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.5 miles

Lobster po-boys, raw oysters, and strong drinks are just a few staples from the Half Shall Raw Bar! This Key West seafood restaurant specializes in oysters, clams, shrimp, and other seafood dishes that are delicious raw or cooked. It's a low key restaurant for a fun and casual lunch or dinner.

Hot Tin Roof
305.296.7701
0 Duval Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.9 miles

This Key West restaurant arguably has one of the best views of the islands. The menu is set up in a way that you can have an entree or easily share a number of small dishes, so it's a great place to go with friends or a date. Don't miss an unforgettable meal while also enjoying one of our famous Key West sunsets. 

Latitudes
305.292.5394
245 Front Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.9 miles

Latitudes is the perfect Key West restaurant for a relaxing, slow, romantic dinner on the beach. Start your special evening with the short boat ride over to your own little island paradise and enjoy an elegant atmosphere and an exquisite meal.

La Trattoria
305.296.1075
524 Duval Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.8 miles

After a long day of swimming, shopping, and general Key West activities, this is the perfect meal. An Italian favorite with a nice atmosphere located right on Duval, La Trattoria is authentic Italian cuisine whose menu boasts a great selection of pasta, seafood, steaks.

Louie's Backyard
305.294.1061
700 Waddell Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.5 miles

The “upstairs” at Louie's Backyard has a deft hand at creating the most inspiring, creative, delicious, and memorable "small plates" you will encounter. Although this restaurant is a little on the nicer side, it's still Key West casual, with indoor and outdoor seating and a great little cocktail bar for having a drink and relaxing by their small beach.

Mangia Mangia
305.294.2469
900 Southard Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.4 miles

With both indoor and outdoor seating available for your comfort, Mangia Mangia has good food for a good value. The pasta is made from scratch, the seafood is fresh, and the atmosphere is inviting.

Margaritaville
305.292.1435
500 Duval Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.8 miles

Ready to waste away in Margaritaville? From the enchantingly tasty drinks, fantastic food, and the ongoing dance party, you might want to spend your whole trip here! Jimmy Buffet fans will enjoy the stories from the bartenders, while lovers of the island lifestyle will enjoy the laid-back island feel of the restaurant. This is a great place to eat as well as chill out with a large margarita and enjoy the ocean breeze.

Michaels
305.295.1300
532 Margaret
Distance From Hotel: 2.4 miles

Great drinks, delicious food, and amazing atmosphere in the heart of old town. This place is away from all the hustle and bustle of Duval street is known for its savory filets, meatloaf, and veal. Local, fresh seafood is delivered daily and the servers are some of the most friendly and knowledgeable in Key West!

Seven Fish
305.296.2777
632 Olivia Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.5 miles

Escape the Duval Street partying in this classy, quiet setting. Seven Fish creates excellent local seafood dishes that are thoughtfully prepared, wonderfully presented, and of course...delicious! This quaint little restaurant has limited seating available, so book in advance. 

Southernmost Beach Café
305.295.6550
1405 Duval Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.7 miles

Breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a view! The Southernmost Beach Cafe is located at the end of Duval street and guests have beach access after eating there. Enjoy a great deal, tropical drinks, and fun dishes in which you can roast your own fish and veggies over a small flame at your table!

Rusty Anchor
305.296.2893
5510 5th Avenue
Distance From Hotel: 1.5 miles

This seafood restaurant is off the beaten path, but is well worth the voyage! A local favorite, this restaurant is known for its fresh catch of the day. If they aren’t serving it, they didn’t catch it that morning! Located in Stock Island just outside of Key West, it’s just a five minute drive from The Inn at Key West!

Turtle Kraals
305.294.2640
231 Margaret Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.5 miles 

If you’re looking for an outstanding happy hour special and the best wings in Key West, Turtle Kraals is the restaurant for you! Their "Southern Pride" smoker oven and an open flame mesquite grill serves the freshest seafood and wings in town. 

Virgilios’s
305.296.8118
524 Duval Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.8 miles

For over ten years Virgilios’s Martini Bar has been a locals favorite, attracting locals and tourist alike for classic cocktails, live music, and late night dancing in our inviting garden bar setting.

AZUR Restaurant
305.292.2987
425 Grinnell Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.3 miles

Is a unique dining experience featuring Mediterranean specialties. Whether you choose our shaded terrace or the comfort of our cool blue dining room, please join us for a hearty breakfast featuring a few new twists, an al fresco lunch by the waterfall, or an intimate dinner with offerings including old favorites and new creations. For a completely different dining experience in Old Town, AZUR is a must on your list of innovative-chef restaurants in Key West

Salute!
305.292.1117 
1000 Atlantic Blvd
Distance From Hotel: 2.3 miles

On The Beach is a Key West treasure. Combining the dining excellence of well-loved sister-restaurant Blue Heaven, with the atmosphere of a lovely beach-side cafe, Salute! On The Beach is Italian prepared with our island lifestyle and tastes in mind. Featuring lighter, Caribbean-influenced takes on Italian classics—with fresh breads, vegetables and local seafood—Salute! On The Beach is a Key West tradition for locals and visitors alike.

Harpoon Harry's
305.294.8744
832 Caroline Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.5 miles

Is located on Caroline St and is a favorite of locals and visitors alike.  It’s a small breakfast-lunch diner and the walls are glass doors that open onto the street. Service begins at 6:30 a.m., serving everything from café-con-leche & cuban egg sandwiches to the more traditional breakfast of eggs, bacon, grits, pancakes and waffles.

Pepe's Café
305.294.7192
806 Caroline Street
Distance From Hotel: 2.5 miles

Established in 1909 Pepe's is the oldest restaurant in town, having recently celebrated their 100th anniversary.  They are open every day from 7:30 a.m. - 10:00 p.m. and are located on the old commercial  waterfront of Caroline Street. At breakfast time they serve everything from traditional breakfast and build your own omelets, to pancakes to creamed chipped beef.  They use real butter, jumbo eggs, and Hormel bacon, make homemade home fries and have great grits.  They also have homemade granola and lots of fresh fruit to choose from.  Their homemade sweet breads are a treat, and you might want to accompany your meal with a fresh squeezed orange juice or a cup of Chock Ful O' Nuts coffee or a screwdriver made with fresh squeezed orange juice.